This week, New America Media released the results of a poll showing the attitudes of different ethnic groups toward opportunity and the American Dream. According to the poll, 74% of Latinos, 64% of Asians, and 44% of African Americans believe in the American Dream (defined as "if you work hard, you will succeed in the U.S.). When asked whether every American has the equal opportunity to succeed, 59% of Latinos, 43% of Asians, and 30% of African Americans strongly agreed.
While the methodology of the poll was somewhat flawed (for example, it took into account the difference in attitudes expressed by Asians depending on their country of origin but not Latinos, who are an incredibly diverse population), overall the results affirmed that the American Dream is alive and well in the hearts of many new Americans. On the one hand, the results are not surprising, since immigrants tend to self-select for the most optimistic and hard-working among a population. On the other hand, the findings are significant at a time when open hostility toward immigrants is being voiced by the media and many of our presidential candidates.
That African Americans are far more skeptical about America being a place where they have equal opportunity and a chance to achieve the American Dream is also significant, and shows the fault lines that exist between the experiences of different ethnic groups in our nation. It would be interesting to know why people think the American Dream is or isn't reachable, and what accounts for the differences between ethnic groups.
The poll results are also an interesting contrast to one conducted a year ago by the Aspen Institute, in which racial and ethnic backgrounds were not taken into account. That poll found the following:
"--While 81 percent agree that America is the land of opportunity, the
idea is not something that is being realized, it is simply an abstract
concept.
-- Today, 61 percent of Americans say they are not living the American Dream.
-- 61 percent of Americans who aren't living the Dream say they do not
believe that they will ever reach the American Dream in their lifetime.
-- 75 percent say the American Dream is somewhat broken, with just 1 in 4 saying it is "alive and well" today.
-- 9 in 10 agree that it is harder to achieve the American Dream than ever before.
-- In addition, just 49 percent agree that if you work hard and play by
the rules, you can lead a solid middle class life. 51 percent of
Americans disagree with that statement."
Further polls along the lines of what the Aspen Institute and the New America Media conducted should offer a rich and varied picture of how different groups of Americans view the American Dream. In addition, when it is complete, Hope Street Group's Economic Opportunity Index will offer a quantitative perspective on which groups of Americans have the most access to opportunity today, and what is most important to achieving it. Quantitative and qualitative studies combined should offer a complete and varied picture of the state of the American Dream, indicators of where our policies are falling short, and point to what we can do as a nation to rebuild the American Dream for everybody.